← Community

Marketing · AI

Our Advisor Called Our Email AI slop (Even Though 25% of People Opened It)

Kiran Panjwani · October 8, 2026

One of our advisors replied to our Fastlane launch email with something that stung: "This smells bloated genai."

Not "congrats on the launch" or "cool feature." Just that.

The thing is, 25% of people opened the email. That's not bad. Most people weren't filtering it out. But one person who knows us well immediately smelled something off.

That feedback was a slap on the wrist I didn't know I needed.

What makes an email smell like AI

I kept thinking about what made it read like slop. It wasn't any specific phrase. I didn't write "I hope this email finds you well" or "I'm excited to announce." I wasn't trying to sound corporate.

The problem was length. Too much detail.

When you write a long email that re-explains everything, adds context people don't need, and walks through every feature like you're filing a report, that's the tell. AI loves detail. It loves being thorough. It doesn't know when to stop.

A real email from a founder to people who already know what you're building? It's shorter. It assumes context. It doesn't re-sell the entire vision every time.

Writing the next one like a text to a friend

So for the follow-up email, I'm writing it like I'd text a friend.

That means:

  • Cut the detail. If they're on the list, they know what Fastlane is. I don't need to explain it again.
  • Add something personal. I'm running a 10K on Saturday. Throwing that in makes it clear a human wrote this, not a bot optimizing for completeness.
  • Send a short reminder instead of re-teaching everything. "Hey, Fastlane is live, here's the link, let me know what you think" beats three paragraphs of setup.

The advisor who called out the first email would never get a text from me that read like a product announcement. So why would the email?

What we're tracking to see if it works

Open rates told us the first email wasn't a disaster. But they don't tell us if people actually engaged or just skimmed and moved on.

For this next one, I'm watching:

  • Replies. Do people actually respond, or is it radio silence?
  • Click-throughs. Are they going to the link, or just opening out of habit?
  • Tone of responses. Do they feel like they're talking to a person or a product?

If the friend-style approach works, we'll see it in how people react, not just whether they open.

One advisor's blunt feedback might end up being the most useful thing we got from the launch.

Written by Kiran Panjwani with Yapship.

More on Marketing and AI